The publishing world has never been more fascinating than it is right now. While we often hear about global bestsellers and universal reading trends, the reality is far more inconsistent – each major English-speaking country has developed its own distinct literary personality. From America’s billion-dollar romance obsession to Britain’s fantasy revolution, the differences are obvious and reveal something meaningful about cultural preferences..
Books Mentioned in this Article
(Affiliate links may earn us a small commission, but not always. The price stays the same for you in any case.)
Romance: The Great Genre Divide
Romance reigns supreme in the United States with an absolutely staggering $1.44 billion in annual sales. American readers consume romance novels at an almost unprecedented rate – averaging 5+ books per month, making subscription services like Kindle Unlimited or Kobo Plus essential for this dedicated readership. The demographic is overwhelmingly female (85%) aged 18-45, and they’re driving the explosive growth of romantasy, which has seen 40% year-over-year growth.
But here’s where it gets interesting: In the United Kingdom, fantasy has emerged as the dominant force, with science fiction and fantasy book sales rising 41.3% between 2023 and 2024. While romance still performs well, British readers have clearly embraced dragons, magic, and otherworldly adventures in a way that sets them apart from their American cousins.
Canada follows North American patterns more closely, with romance maintaining strong performance, but even Canadian publishers are increasingly focusing on romantasy titles as a bridge between American romance preferences and the growing global fantasy trend.
The Mystery/Thriller Exception: The Universal Page-Turner
If there’s one genre that transcends borders, it’s mystery and thriller fiction. It maintains remarkably consistent appeal across all English-speaking markets, accounting for 19.1% of the UK fiction market.
Australian and New Zealand markets show particularly strong performance for mystery/thriller, possibly due to their rich traditions in crime fiction. Australia has a documented 200-year history of crime fiction, since the early 1800s, stemming naturally from its origins as a penal colony.
The genre’s universal appeal makes sense – a good psychological thriller or police procedural doesn’t need cultural translation to keep readers turning pages at 2 AM.
Another factor that makes the genre so popular is that it translates exceptionally well to audiobook format, making it perfect for commuters and multitaskers on platforms like Audible and Libro.fm.
The Romantasy Revolution: Bridging Divides
Perhaps the most fascinating development of 2025 is the rise of romantasy, like A Court of Thorns and Roses series. The romance-fantasy hybrid genre is conquering cultural boundaries with $610 million in global sales in 2024. Romantasy serves as a perfect bridge between American romance preferences and European fantasy enthusiasm.
The #DarkRomanceBookTok hashtag has generated millions of views, demonstrating how social media transcends national boundaries to create global reading communities. British readers have particularly embraced romantasy as it satisfies their growing appetite for fantasy elements while maintaining the emotional satisfaction that makes romance so irresistible.
Young Adult Fiction: A Genre in Transition
Young Adult fiction continues to command significant attention in 2025, with literary agents ranking it as their most sought-after genre. YA is experiencing strategic evolution, expanding its boundaries while maintaining core appeal.
The publishing industry’s enthusiasm for YA stems from compelling factors. YA titles offer exceptional crossover potential, regularly capturing both teen and adult audiences when they succeed: 78% of YA buyers are actually adults over 18, with 51% of purchases coming from readers aged 30-44.
Regional variations show interesting patterns: YA fiction sales increased 7.4% in the UK during 2024, while Canada sees YA representing 40% of all English-language book sales.
Trending YA subgenres include dark academia themes, LGBTQ+ narratives, and YA horror, all showing particular strength heading into 2025. The genre’s focus on character development, emotional intensity, and transformative experiences continues to appeal to readers seeking both escapism and personal connection.
Science Fiction: The Consistent Niche
Science fiction occupies a unique position in the publishing world. Its readership skews toward adults aged 30-45, with above-average wealth and education levels. What makes sci-fi readers particularly interesting is that they’re persistent, high-volume readers who are highly educated and interested in science.
Science fiction is also strong in audiobook format, with Canadian data showing that 41% of audiobook listeners have consumed science fiction and fantasy content, making it the most popular audiobook genre. While industry tracking typically combines science fiction with fantasy, making pure science fiction data difficult to isolate, the genre shows consistent international appeal across English-speaking markets.
Sci-fi also benefits from significant self-publishing success, particularly in hard subgenres, where authors can respond quickly to technological trends and serve niche audiences who seek out specific content.
A Few Reasons Behind Each Country’s Reading Preferences
Cultural Psychology: Americans gravitate toward emotional satisfaction and escapism through romance, while research shows that European stress relief often comes through cognitive engagement rather than pure escapism. Fantasy’s complex narratives, detailed world-building, and intricate plotting may provide more mental stimulation, while romance offers more emotional involvement.
Social Media Influence: BookTok and similar platforms create global communities, but they intensify regional differences rather than eliminate them. American BookTok creators focus on emotional reactions, reinforcing the cultural emphasis that drives romance’s dominance. European creators emphasize world-building discussions and fantasy lore breakdowns, reflecting the intellectual engagement preference that fuels fantasy’s growth.
Publishing Infrastructure: Different distribution systems, bookstore cultures, and marketing approaches in each country reinforce regional preferences. What gets promoted heavily in American bookstores differs significantly from other countries’ displays. American bookstores dedicate entire sections and promotional displays to romance novels, with dedicated ‘Bookstore Romance Day’ events, for example, as UK bookstores prominently feature fantasy and science fiction sections, often dedicating ‘full half floors to fantasy and sci-fi’ with signed first editions and premium displays.
Are Reading Preferences Becoming More Similar Worldwide?
We’re probably heading toward some overlapping preferences. Romantasy’s growth indicates that successful genres will be those that blend traditional boundaries, appealing to diverse audiences across different markets. Mystery/thriller’s universal appeal will likely continue, while pure romance may remain primarily American and fantasy may strengthen its European foothold.
The global fiction market, valued at $11.38 billion in 2025 and projected to reach $12.09 billion by 2029, shows that despite regional differences, the appetite for fiction is growing everywhere. The question isn’t whether people will read – it’s what they’ll choose to read, and which fascinating cultural fingerprints are behind their choices. The only universal truth is that we all love a good story.
Bestsellers by Country & Preferred Genre
Since consolidated 2025 data isn’t available yet, let’s wrap up by listing some 2024’s bestselling fiction in each country, based on their preferred genres.
United States – Romance
Funny Story by Emily Henry – When your fiancé dumps you for his best friend’s girlfriend, the logical response is obviously to fake-date the other victim of this romantic clusterfuck. What could go wrong? Everything, in the most deliciously messy way possible.
Canada – Romance
This Summer Will Be Different by Carley Fortune – Lucy has been secretly lusting after her best friend’s brother for years. This summer on Prince Edward Island, she’s finally going to do something about it – consequences be damned. Spoiler: there are consequences.
United Kingdom – Fantasy
The Familiar by Leigh Bardugo – In an alternate Spanish Inquisition where magic gets you burned at the stake, a young woman discovers she’s got the kind of power that could topple kingdoms. Now she just has to survive long enough to use it.
Australia – Mystery/Thriller
Ripper by Shelley Burr is a gripping Australian crime thriller set in the small town of Rainier, haunted by murders from seventeen years ago.
When a dark tourism operator is brutally killed in what appears to be a copycat murder, tea shop owner Gemma Guillory gets drawn into the investigation.